Follow Vogue Arabia

Justin Baldoni Responds to Claims That It Ends With Us Glorifies Domestic Violence

Justin Baldoni has addressed criticism that his new film, It Ends With Us, glorifies domestic violence.

justin-baldoni

Photo: Getty

Speaking to the Associated Press, the actor and director, who stars as abusive husband Ryle Kincaid opposite Blake Lively’s Lily Bloom, said that critics are “are absolutely entitled to that opinion, and it makes perfect sense as to why they would feel that way.”

He continued, “Look, we live in a culture where, unfortunately, too many things are glorified. And we are fighting for attention, we’re in an attention economy…and so it makes perfect sense that people would feel that way.”

“Also, if anybody has had that real-life [domestic violence] experience, I can imagine how hard it would be to imagine their experience being in a romance novel,” he said. “To them I would just offer that we were very intentional in the making of this movie.”

This statement comes amid rampant online speculation that there was discord behind the scenes of the film adaptation of Colleen Hoover’s best-selling novel, It Ends With Us, which has also faced criticism for mishandling the sensitive subject matter. The book and movie follow Lily Bloom’s journey toward ending the generational cycle of domestic violence while also tracking another love story between Bloom and her childhood love, Atlas Corrigan (played in the film by Brandon Sklenar).

Fans first began to suspect there was an issue between Justin Baldoni and the rest of the cast when he didn’t pose with anyone from the production at the film’s premiere on August 6. After doing some digging, fans noticed Baldoni had been largely absent from previous press events and had seemingly been unfollowed by a majority of the cast and Hoover on social media. Both Lively and Jenny Slate (who plays Ryle’s sister Allysa) also appeared to dodge direct questions about the director during interviews.

While some social media users have theorized that Justin Baldoni acted poorly on set, others believe this tension was the result of a power struggle between the director and Lively, who served as co-executive producer on the project and has been vocal about her creative contributions to the film alongside her husband, Ryan Reynolds. Despite the speculative nature of the discourse, fans have begun choosing sides — with the conversation largely favoring Justin Baldoni based on the way both parties have chosen to speak about the project.

Like Hoover, who faced backlash for attempting to release a coloring book based on the novel, Lively is being criticized for marketing the film as a lighthearted romance and promoting her haircare line during the press tour. One particular interview in which Lively told viewers to “grab your friends, wear your florals” to see the film is rubbing many fans the wrong way. Meanwhile, fans have noted that Baldoni’s interviews are largely centered around the film’s depiction of abuse.

“Grab your friends, wear your florals…. but forget the sole purpose of this film is to raise awareness to domestic violence?” one user commented.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by It Ends With Us (@itendswithusmovie)

Neither Justin Baldoni nor Blake Lively have directly commented on the controversy. Even a recent AP interview discusses criticism of the film as a whole, though his reference to the “attention economy” suggests he’s aware of concerns about the press tour. “We’re in a clickbait world and everyone is trying to figure out how to gather attention,” he said. “It’s everywhere around us.”

Some fans think this was a subtle dig at Lively. “This is an ice cold read! He is saying a lot without directly calling Blake and them out,” one user commented on TikTok. Another wrote, “He’s gotta be so frustrated that he put so much sincere work into this films message and ‘others associated with the film’ are doing the opposite.”

For her part, Blake Lively says she wants fans to know that Lily Bloom is not “defined by something that someone else did to her.”

@bbcnews Blake said she felt the “responsibility of servicing the people” that care so much about the book, when bringing Lily to life. #ItEndsWithUs #BlakeLively #LilyBloom #ItEndsWithUsMovie #ColleenHoover #BookTok #ItEndsWithUsBook #BBCNews ♬ original sound – BBC News

“This movie covers domestic violence, but what’s important about this film is that she is not just a survivor, and she’s not just a victim, and while those are huge things to be, they’re not her identity,” she said during a red-carpet interview with BBC News on August 8. “She’s not defined by something that someone else did to her or an event that happened to her, even if it’s multiple events, she defines herself. And I think that that’s deeply empowering, to remind people that no one else can define you, no experience can define you. You define you.”

She continued, “You really feel like we delivered a story that’s emotional and it’s fun and it’s funny and it’s painful and it’s scary and it’s tragic and it’s inspiring, and that’s what life is.”

Whether or not viewers agree with her, of course, is up to them.

Originally published in Glamour.com

Suggestions
Articles
View All
Vogue Collection
Topics