One shadow shade that’s particularly tough to pull off: orange. Similar to red or pink, when improperly swathed across lids, it can create a look reminiscent of a seasonal allergy attack. But here to prove the beauty critics wrong is Gigi Hadid, who wore the hue to the DKNY Memorial Day fundraising dinner in East Hampton on Sunday night. The model played it smart by selecting a golden apricot laced with a metallic pigment, anchoring the color with lush black lashes and keeping the rest of her face relatively bare (save for an allover bronze glow). While you may need to work on your tan (or fake it with our editors’ go-to products), re-creating Hadid’s sunset-like eyes couldn’t be simpler: Apply a wash of Make Up For Ever Diamond Shadow in Diamond Peach with a fluffy brush from lash line to crease and amplify fringe with a few coats of Maybelline New York Volum’ Express Pumped Up! Colossal Waterproof mascara.